Scareware Hits My PC; Now I'm Really Mad
Irony is when something happens in a context in which it shouldn’t have happened, such as my PC getting infected with a piece of nasty “scareware” while writing a report on the effectiveness of browser security features (I’m sure the two are unrelated, but that’s irony). Scareware, or rogue software that masquerades as legitimate security software to trick users into paying for an application that serves no purpose, is a huge and growing problem. Earlier this year, Microsoft reported that rogue software and scareware was the biggest threat for the second half of 2008. Panda Software issued a similar report this spring. For the last 14 hours, I’ve been doing battle with a nasty Trojan that Symantec calls SafeStrip. The Trojan calls itself SPM/LX. Frankly, I don’t care what it is; I’ll just call it “annoying.” The Trojan first caused my machine to grind to a slow crawl and presented me with a brand new trial app called “Advanced Virus Remover.” This app reported that I had several worms and viruses that could only be removed if I converted to a paid license. Naturally, it disabled my Symantec Endpoint Security before overflowing the memory and invoking the dreaded “blue screen of death.” The damn thing wouldn’t allow me to reboot in safe mode and made the embedded recovery tools nearly useless. After more than an hour of wrestling with Trojan, I finally got Windows operating in a stable state. Symantec claims it quarantined the malware, but did nothing to disable it or restore functionality of useful tools as Task Manager. Like many similar pieces of malware, this Trojan is interfering with access and functionality. A Facebook friend suggested I read Panda Security’s report on scareware. While the Trojan allowed me to reach the Panda site, it wouldn’t allow me to access the PDF file. Interestingly, the Trojan is blocking access to search engines Ask.com and Bing, but allowing unfettered access to Google (someone has already suggested that this is Google’s way of blunting Microsoft’s gains with Bing - not bloody likely). SafeStrip is a persistent bugger. While my admin is working on removing it through our corporate AV server, it continues to present me with a steady diet of dire warnings about the need to scan my PC, download the latest intrusion prevention software and the danger of operating without AV protection. The creators have gone to great lengths to make this scareware look legitimate. Its icon on the desktop and tool tray look exactly like the four-color shield Microsoft uses for its security products. The warnings, system pop-ups and interface look just like any anti-virus application. Even the about tab on the app is remarkably ambiguous but somewhat believable to neophytes; it reads, “Use the Interest with confidence (sic) Anti-Virus, Anti-Spyware, Anti-Spam and Firewall protection. Advanced Virus Remover detects and stops threats before they become a problem.” Malware infections can nearly be cleaned up in nearly all instances with varying degrees of residual damage. I can even live with the annoyance and disruption caused by the Trojan while my team cleans my machine. But I can envision how this already serious and growing threat could become more severe. Hapless end users readily giving up credit card numbers and identifying information to these fraudsters and setting themselves up to be chronically bilked for cash. Worse, scareware such as Advanced Virus Remover want to update themselves, and that will prompt users to download keystroke loggers and other spyware that will stealthily steal information. And, of course, these apps are great gateways for creating botnets. I’m not scared of scareware; I’m just pissed off. It’s time for war against these bastards. Even as some states attorneys general look to prosecute these fraudsters, the security community and solution providers need to raise the level of awareness of drive-by downloads, scareware and rogue applications. In this case, awareness is a critical component of the defense. |

Comments (25)
The punishment for creating scareware should be execution. Cap the rear of a few of these bastards and the problem should take care of itself.
Posted by Jack | August 13, 2009 3:45 PM
I just spend over 6 hours in the task of removing a similar nasty application that performed the same actions. I believe that this should require a completed format to clear up the issue but time was of the essence in this instance causing the effort to resolve just short of that action. This little critter was even worse. After a previous two hour process I had thought I got rid of the malware but was surprised the next day when it started back up and even exhibited even worse popups and finally C5 bluescreens. After suspecting a possible rootkit, which was confirmed finally using McAfee's rootkit tool. But the registry that contained the "Sky'Crapware'" entry had locked down and could not be deleted because the Malware had remove all rights to the entry. After reviewing the entry I discovered which Device driver sys file was causing the blue screens and deleted it from the system32 directory. The McAfee app did rename and/or delete the other modules and registry entries.
I just cannot understand why MS choose not to block all, except for approval, RootKit installations and registry entries out of the box.
Making money on this insidious malware is just not for the creator.
Posted by IT Tech | August 13, 2009 4:14 PM
This sounds like a great way to get people to give up credit card and identity information. If someone's selling a phony product why should they be trusted with anything else? Be a real easy way to get info they could exploit for other purposes, even if the cc is canceled they have the person's other info, so the game goes on.
Posted by Paul Braga | August 13, 2009 4:27 PM
I don't know why the Credit Card companies don't take more of a lead on this kind of stuff. It would be pretty hard to for the perpetrators of this stuff to make any money if they couldn't received funds through a merchant account.
Posted by Robert | August 13, 2009 4:59 PM
You've made it this far without contracting this? I've seen it and its variants plenty of times with many different security software programs running and up-to-date.
Yes, a real threat but not so difficult to deal with using tools those of us on the front lines use all the time. To the uninitiated, it presents a huge hazard.
Posted by BTDT | August 13, 2009 5:48 PM
This sounds a lot like a variant of either the Antivirus 2008/2009 scamware or something I encountered on a customer's computer a couple of weeks ago called Personal Antivirus, which performed similarly to the AV200x series. I have always had good success removing the AV200x with MalwareBytes, but it had no effect whatsoever on the Personal AV scamware. So I then found and installed a removal tool called SuperAntiSpyware, or SAS for short, and it did a wonderful job of destroying every remnant of the Personal AV.
Posted by Jim T | August 13, 2009 6:51 PM
So, interesting observation about who gets rich off of this -- the creator of the malware, the antivirus and the platform. Interestingly, my Vista machine didn't get whacked. I wonder if Vista's requirements for user approval for new installation guards against drive-by downloads and Trojan installations? I haven't looked at Vista that way.
Posted by Larry Walsh
| August 13, 2009 7:16 PM
So, we're now officially on Day 2 of this infection. My admin spent the afternoon repeatedly cleaning out the registry only to have this Trojan rear its ugly head again. At least the BSOD have stopped. So far, he's used MalwareBytes, Spyware Doctor and Ad-Aware. None worked. Tomorrow, we're going to try a few more tricks. If that doesn't work, we're going nuclear.
Posted by Larry Walsh
| August 13, 2009 7:25 PM
I had the same happen 2 days ago. It even changing my wallpaper to solid blue with the virus warning in the center. According to what little research I could, it also installs in the startup. I eventually found the program, (or so I think I got it all), on my hard drive by doing a search of my C drive using "advance". I located 2 entries and a folder called "C:\program files\advancedvirusremover". Deleted the items and so far have stayed up and running.
I have dial up access and didn't expect any drive by shootings. I picked it up on IWON.com playing Spin 2 Win.
Posted by Richard Ketchum | August 13, 2009 8:29 PM
Maybe this will help,
Their support puts this out. Probably to prevent prosecution.
Please follow my instructions to uninstall Personal Antivirus
1.Open My computer, choose Disk C;
2.Find the folder Program Files\Common Files\Uninstal\PAV\Uninstall.exe;
3.Run the file Uninstall.exe
After that our product will be removed.
Feel free to contact us if you need any help
support@softsupportmail.com
We have removed this from customers machines very cleanly. When all else fails - Google! That's how we found it.
Posted by Steve | August 13, 2009 10:04 PM
These type of infections rely on social engineering as well, I tell all my customers to never close any dialog/ display boxes when they pop up by the use of even the close "X". They have recoded the X to read "yes install". I tell them to stop them using task manager and killing any open Web Browser and you will also see the Nasty program box as well. Then Use ATF Cleaner, MBAM, Spybot S&D, SAS, and your AV program too. All of that before letting it shut down.
Posted by DaveThe Computer Guy | August 13, 2009 10:05 PM
Dave, I hear you loud and clear, and that was the first thing I went to do. But this little bug disabled my Task Master.
Posted by Larry Walsh
| August 13, 2009 11:08 PM
Scareware is expensive to try to repair and, in any "repair" situation seems often to leave the victim machine with some hidden beacon.
Best, fastest, cheapest and only really through fix is restore/reinstall the OS.
Scareware is a great reason to get into off-site versioned backups. Then, if the OS's built-in restore is made ineffectual by the scareware, you just "reinstall" and reload the backup. Cool
PS: To imprision or get restitution or whatever the punishiment is, I'd settle for any action at all by DHS agencies to stop this sort of crime. Any action at all?
Posted by Mike Pepper ~ Computer Guy | August 14, 2009 11:54 AM
Ironically, I just had to clear up a PC for my daughter the other evening with a similar "Scareware" called "Personal Anti-Virus". I just gave my daughters an older PC that I had and set it up with Vista Ultimate. I installed my daughters copy of NAV 2008 and she failed to register it, so it didn't protect it against this nasty booger. Anyway, I did the smart thing and made an image, yes 6 DVD-DL's worth of the installation, prior to giving it to them and restored the computer, so all they lost, was a couple of photos they downloaded from some friends. I also installed my licensed copy of Norton 360 for this computer and turned UAC back on for them. I failed to tell them that Vista will not install anything, unless they think about it first. So now they know to call me 1st, before installing anything.
Posted by Dean Warnock | August 14, 2009 3:44 PM
The only way to beat these scammers is either in the pocketbook or jail time. I say a class action lawsuit billing them at triple full cost for the time it takes techs to remove the malware. Or better still, some international laws with teeth that would lead to jail time. Maybe even block entire countries IP range if they don't enforce compliance.
Posted by Gary Lamagna | August 14, 2009 4:46 PM
Mr. Walsh:
I just have to make this observation...the only way to get this type of scareware is to be stupid enough to install it! I have ran into numerous websites (haaretz.com is one that is frequently compromised and attempts to install scareware 1 our every 10 times when I access news articles). The website runs a "fake" scan, and than gives you a choice to either fix the "found" virues and trojans or cancel. Either button will attempt to download the malicious file. All I do is cancel the dowload and if needed end task to close the site. It seems to me that you ran the executable and installed the fake AntiVirus/Anti Malware software. Me thinks maybe you should find another line of work....
Posted by Asif Mirza | August 14, 2009 5:42 PM
Your observations are interesting in that they are baseless and myopic. The pervassiveness of malware and ability of hackers to circumvent user actions and technical controls makes such infections not only possible but probable. As many people have written to this blog, this type of infection is not a matter of if but when. Even legimtate sites are being compromised by hackers to spread their malicious wares, and this had led to attempts by AV vendors to assess and filter such sites based on their discreet security posture and long-term reputation. Stupidity, sir, is a factor, but increasingly a smaller factor than in the past.
Posted by Larry Walsh
| August 14, 2009 6:00 PM
What puzzles me is that large companies haven't seen this kind of deliberate infection and waste of IT resources as a pure business decision and have these guys capped?
Seriously- what is the cost to huge companies in terms of virii/infection abatement? It has to be in the millions. Thousands of hours lost across a company quickly means millions in revenue. If 1 company took the lead ( albeit a morally questionable one--to someone, sure as hell not me--) and hired some eastern block spook to find who's responsible and gut them like a carp, the world would start being a better place quickly. I say this is war and we should be treating it as such.
While they're at it, see if they'd do Alan Ralsky and his ilk for an extra hundred K, everyone would be happy to chip in a few bucks. Added bonus is that half of these guys are from some backwater former russky republic or North Korea anyway and it's not like they have a statute of limitations in Crapspamistan.
Whatever ass said violence isnt the answer wasnt asking the right question.
Posted by Cracker Leroy | August 14, 2009 8:11 PM
Well, interesting idea, but not practical. If the terrorist groups have taught us anything its that removing the head does not kill the body.
Posted by Larry Walsh
| August 14, 2009 8:46 PM
While I would agree in the instance of ideologues, these are merely opportunists who are motivated by money and by preserving their own skin. If corporal responses didnt work, then there'd be little if any point in establishing a rule of law in the first place. Further, the head, greed, is fundamentally inaccessable being an inextricable component of human nature. Im not even speaking in terms of a social movement, but as a, shall we say, corporate initiative. Word gets around quickly when bodies start piling up.
Personally, its a whole lot more ethical than political action committees, wouldnt you say? and with respect to terrorists, they've shown that senseless bloodshed results in concessionary politics and asskissery to statistically irrelevant fringe dwellers.
Regardless, many of the viruses and bot-nets originate out of the *vakias, where programmers are actively recruited by the Russian Mob, many of whom are former KGB and even economists. The point here, is that John Law and Flaccid McAttorney, impotent mouth-breathers that they are, cannot and will not help. Witness the astoundlingly vacant Can-Spam Act which has resulted in... Anyone... Buhler? MORE SPAM! It all went off-shore. And a few small fish went to club fed.
If there's any results that can be had, they most certainly will not be from legislators, but from the cold, enterprising hand of people who refuse to take it anymore. So the only question that I have is who's in charge of the discretionary budget over at IBM?
We should talk.Posted by crackerLeroy | August 14, 2009 11:08 PM
have you tried Hijack This? I had pretty good success with it against Antivirus 2008. It didn't get everything but it did disable it, at which point I was able to run Spybot, do a registry scrub, etc....
Posted by justwondering | August 15, 2009 11:37 AM
I am not totally computer literate, and I just purchased the Advanced Virus Remover for $69.00. All sorts of things were popping up and I could not figure it out after trying yesterday and today. Is there a way I can get my money back? I feel like such a fool to let them dupe me into doing this. Somebody tell me what to do please.
Posted by Phyllis | August 15, 2009 2:40 PM
I just got one thats called Total Security. It changed my background on my desktop, I can't open ANY programs, not even the task manager! On top of that I can't even run Windows(XP) in safe mode. Mr. Walsh, any update on your situation? How do I get this off? I foolishly don't have any backups, and would like to get back to normal without reinstalling Windows, but its not the end of the world if I have to. I just want to try everything first before doing so...Hell, I don't even know where my windows cd is...The biggest thing I'm worried about is that I have Visual Studio 2008 Professional and in the middle of a big and awesome open source project, and I don't know where my VS2008 cd is :-( Guess I better get looking for both
Posted by Justin | August 16, 2009 3:49 AM
I wonder if you could make a claim with the credit card company for a fraudlent purchase. Now that would be an interesting experiment.
I had some mystery charges show up on my cellphone bill. When I called AT&T to inquire, they could only tell me that it was a third-party charging against my account for ringtone downloads -- which I had never done. Without question, they refunded my money. It would be interesting to see if the same could apply to scareware.
Posted by Larry Walsh
| August 16, 2009 7:27 PM
I encountered Green AV 2009 on a customer's computer and googled for a solution. I found several. None worked. In fact, with some of the sites, as has been mentioned earlier, there were entries that seemed to be purposely misleading- removing some of the infection but leaving other parts that allowed it to continue to operate.
I didn't trust any of the old standbys, such as Malwarebytes, to completely remove the thing, since the various instructions on the internet are wrong. I didn't want a partial removal that would hid the total signature of the problem.
I believe I have a process that removed all the threads, but it required a long time using HighJackThis, reviewing and searching the registry, and cross referencing the registry to the possible modules on the computer, etc.
On another customer's computer I had a W32Lovegate variant. That one had disabled windows update by deleting an entire branch of the registry. Working with MS Support, we had to reconstruct the branch, as well as run a couple of different malware programs. Now I have the branch as a local reg file, as well as all the other things I did in "snapshot form" so I can quickly go after the thing if I again encounter it.
These are all stories to the question I have. How in the world can the good guys communicate amongst each other without the bad guys mucking up the information or using it to change their "signature." Do we have to end up sending the information to the big Security Application sites, where they then use the information to make a profit? Is there some web site where solutions I find, get some credit, and not have the information misused?
Posted by Duane Leet | August 17, 2009 3:55 PM